I don't think it clealy said what the punishment was for the first and second time.=, but I know the third time you break a major jule you are released.
People can be released without punishment in scenarios where the giver believes that forgiveness or rehabilitation is more beneficial than retribution. This can happen in cases where the offender shows genuine remorse, takes responsibility for their actions, and demonstrates a commitment to change. Additionally, factors such as the severity of the offense, the individual's background, and the potential for reintegration into society may also influence the decision to release without punishment.
Release
As correcting or punishment
In the book "The Giver," breaking the laws in the community can result in consequences such as public shame, loss of privileges, or even release from the community (which is later revealed to mean euthanasia). The severity of the punishment depends on the nature of the offense and its impact on the community.
In the giver what were the two occasions when release was not a punishment
In "The Giver," the punishment for arriving to school late was public chastisement in front of the class by the Teacher. The student was also given a warning which would be recorded in their permanent record.
If you were old or disabled like gabe
You can refer to the related link below for quotes from the book .
no he leaves but does not get released
The Giver movie has not yet been made but have said that it will be released in 2013
The term for transitioning out into the community from "The Giver" is "Release." In the context of the novel, individuals who are released are essentially euthanized or eliminated from the community.