I imagine like all collectables there are points of condition and variation, etc. One apparently sold for $89 at goantiques.com: http://www.goantiques.com/detail,indian-service-button,1802713.html
Chat with our AI personalities
A 1905 Indian Head cent in average circulated condition has a retail value of $1.00$3.00
The last year for the series of Indian head cents was 1909. If it is a US Lincoln cents dated 1925, the value is 10 to 25 cents depending on condition.
The US first issued nickels in 1866, and Indian head (buffalo) nickels were minted from 1913 to 1938.
Look at the coin again. No U.S. $1.00 silver coins have the Indian Head design.
No dimes have been made by the US with a "Indian" on them, look at the coin again find the date and post new question with that information.