0
Was the Sixteenth Amendment designed to affirm the Supreme Court's prior decisions about Federal income tax?
The Sixteenth Amendment both affirmed and disaffirmed the US Supreme Court's varying decisions on federal tax issues, but the purpose of the amendment was primarily to correct what Congress considered an error in the decision of Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co., 157 US 429 (1895). In Pollock, the Court overturned the entire Wilson-Gorman Act of 1894, in part because it mislabeled some parts of the Act as an unconstitutional levy of "direct taxes," and in part because the Court held the Act wasn't intended to generate revenue solely from the remaining constitutional income tax sections.
The decision in Pollock was in direction contradiction to that of Springer v. US, 102 US 586 (1881) which allowed the federal government to assess income tax on real estate in order to revive the Treasury after the US Civil War.
Following the Pollock decision, the Court appeared to develop an awareness of the threat to the Treasury's solvency and upheld Congress' decisions to levy "excise taxes," which required fewer restrictions. In a series of later cases (Nicol v. Ames, (1899); Knowlton v. Moore, (1900); and Patton v. Brady, (1902)) the Supreme Court held constitutional taxes on merchandise, commodity exchanges and inheritance, among other things.
Congress had a reasonable concern, however, that future Courts might reverse this constitutional construct and eliminate important sources of Federal income. In order to maintain economic stability, Congress proposed the Sixteenth Amendment, fixing established tax practices as constitutional without having to rely on the Supreme Court. The Amendment also relieved the burdensome apportionment requirement. The Sixteenth Amendment, ratified in 1913, removed de facto taxing power from the Judicial branch, and returned it to the Legislative branch, as the Constitution intended.
Amendment XVI
"The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration."
For more information, see Related Questions, below.
No, the Sixteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution was not specifically designed to affirm the Supreme Court's prior decisions about Federal income tax. Rather, it was intended to grant Congress the power to levy an income tax without apportionment among the states. This amendment was ratified in 1913 and allowed for the implementation of a federal income tax system.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Which amendment to the US Constitution instituted federal income tax?
sixteenth amendment
Which amendment to the US Constitution instituted a federal income tax?
sixteenth amendment
What role did the sixteenth amendment play on Woodrow Wilsons efforts to regulate the economy?
The 16th amendment made a federal income tax legal. This tax soon became a major source of revenue for the federal government. By giving tax breaks to businesses and individuals for certain actions, the federal government can regulate to some degree ,at least, many facets of American life and economic activities.
The sixteenth amendment provided for?
A means for congress to levy personal income.
In what amendment was Congress given power to collect income tax?
The 16th Amendment states:The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.It vacated the precedent set by the decision in the case Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co.
What did the sixteenth amendment say?
The Sixteenth Amendment to the US Consitution allows for the Federal Government to apply income taxes unequally across the various states in a method different than simply based on population (i.e. based on income).
Which Amendment established the means for expanded federal action?
The 16th Amendment established the means for expanded federal action by granting Congress the power to levy an income tax. This amendment significantly increased the federal government's ability to raise revenue and fund expanded programs and initiatives.
What amendment gave congress authority to implement a federal income tax?
The sixteenth amendment allows Congress to impose income taxes in their current form.
Which amendment to the Constitution provided the ability for the federal government to collect an income tax from all workers?
The 16th Amendment to the U.S Constitution allows the government to collect the Income Tax.Prior to this amendment, the federal government made an attempt to to create an Income Tax, and the tax was brought to court.The United States Supreme Court ruled that an "Income Tax" was unconstitutional.In response, the Income Tax Amendment was added to the U.S Constitution, making the tax legal.
What caused more opportunities for accountants in 1913?
In 1913, the responsibilities of and job opportunities for accountants again expanded with the ratification of the sixteenth amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which allowed a federal income tax.
When could states collect taxes but the federal government could not?
The federal government had no ability to tax when it was operating under the Articles of Confederation. The US Constitution provided the federal government authority to collect taxes; the Sixteenth Amendment, ratified in 1913, added the ability to levy taxes on income.
What role did the Sixteenth Amendment play on Woodrow Wilson efforts to regulate the economy?
The 16th amendment made a federal income tax legal. This tax soon became a major source of revenue for the federal government. By giving tax breaks to businesses and individuals for certain actions, the federal government can regulate to some degree ,at least, many facets of American life and economic activities.
