0
answer I (shia view)
Umar with some soldiers attacked her home to enforce Ali S.A. to Give Bayat to Abubakr. but Ali S.A. did not accept and did not open the door. Fatima S.A. was behind door that Umar burnt and striken the door with his leg and door broken and she was injured and her baby in her womb was killed and she was in bed until 69 or 95 days later died for that injury. Ali S.A. was at home and when Umar entered home fought with him and got his neck and said: you know well if I have not been promised to prophet to not make civil war now you could not exist this home alive. proof is available from both shia and sunni hadith books. she died at age 18 and how a woman die naturally at age 18?!
Anser II
Sunny view
There is no proof of above given fabricated shia story in any Impartial history .
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
When did Fatima Soltan die?
Fatima Soltan died in 1681.
Who is fatima?
There is no Saint Fatima. However, there is Our Lady of Fatima - the Blessed Virgin as she appeared to the three children at Fatima, Portugal.
When did Fatima Jinnah die?
Fatima Jinnah died on July 8, 1967 at the age of 73.
When did Fatima el-Sharif die?
Fatima el-Sharif died on 2009-10-03.
When did fatima el sharif die?
Fatima el-Sharif died on 2009-10-03.
How old was Fatima Jinnah at death?
Fatima Jinnah died on July 8, 1967 at the age of 73.
How old was fatihma when she died?
Fatima was 29 years old when she died.
How old is fatima?
She was born in the year 605 and died in 632.
How old was Fatima alzahraa when she died?
19
What was the age of Fatima Jinnah when she died?
Fatima Jinnah was born on July 31, 1893 and died on July 9, 1967, so she lived to be 94 years old.
When did Fatima die?
Fatima, in common usage, is a Town in Portugal famed for Religious miracles in the year l9l7 and involving three children as principal witnesses- two of whom were illiterate. Fatima is a town and not, in the usual sense, a person"s name, though it is used as a prename in Arabic.
Which of the prophet mohammed's children died after him?
Hazrat Fatima RA died after death of prophet Muhammad pbuh .
