0
What objection to the proposal does the speaker think the readers might raise and how does he answer this objection in a modest proposal?
The objection the speaker anticipates readers raising is the morality of the proposal to consume infants as a solution to poverty. He answers this objection by presenting the idea in a satirical and exaggerated manner, highlighting the absurdity of the situation and challenging readers to reflect on the root causes of poverty and societal complacency.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What objection to the proposal doesd the speaker think the readers might raise in A Modest Proposal?
One objection the speaker addresses in "A Modest Proposal" is the concern that the proposal suggests treating people as commodities or livestock. The speaker counters this by arguing that the proposal is a legitimate solution to poverty and overpopulation without resorting to inhumane practices.
What objection to the proposal does the speaker think readers might raise how does he answer that objection in a modest proposal?
The speaker anticipates that readers may object to the moral implications of his proposal to use infants for food. He answers this objection by arguing that his proposal would solve economic problems, reduce the population burden, and benefit the impoverished. He uses satire to shock readers into considering the harsh realities of poverty and hunger in Ireland.
What objection does the speaker anticipate in the Modest Proposal?
The speaker anticipates objections to his proposal that the children of the poor be sold as a food source, such as moral concerns about cannibalism and the exploitation of the impoverished. He presents these objections to refute them with his satirical argument.
What objection was Swifts narrator overlooking in A Modest proposal?
One objection the narrator overlooks in A Modest Proposal is the moral and ethical concern regarding the proposal to use children for food. The narrator focuses on the economic benefits and ignores the implications of such a depraved solution.
In A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift what problem does the speaker describe in the opening paragraphs of A Modest Proposal?
In the opening paragraphs of "A Modest Proposal," the speaker describes the dire poverty and overpopulation in Ireland, particularly among the Catholic families. He suggests that the surplus population of impoverished children could be a burden on society.
What objection to the proposal doesd the speaker think the readers might raise in A Modest Proposal?
One objection the speaker addresses in "A Modest Proposal" is the concern that the proposal suggests treating people as commodities or livestock. The speaker counters this by arguing that the proposal is a legitimate solution to poverty and overpopulation without resorting to inhumane practices.
What objection to the proposal does the speaker think readers might raise how does he answer that objection in a modest proposal?
The speaker anticipates that readers may object to the moral implications of his proposal to use infants for food. He answers this objection by arguing that his proposal would solve economic problems, reduce the population burden, and benefit the impoverished. He uses satire to shock readers into considering the harsh realities of poverty and hunger in Ireland.
What objection does the speaker anticipate in the Modest Proposal?
The speaker anticipates objections to his proposal that the children of the poor be sold as a food source, such as moral concerns about cannibalism and the exploitation of the impoverished. He presents these objections to refute them with his satirical argument.
What objection was Swifts narrator overlooking in A Modest proposal?
One objection the narrator overlooks in A Modest Proposal is the moral and ethical concern regarding the proposal to use children for food. The narrator focuses on the economic benefits and ignores the implications of such a depraved solution.
In A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift what problem does the speaker describe in the opening paragraphs of A Modest Proposal?
In the opening paragraphs of "A Modest Proposal," the speaker describes the dire poverty and overpopulation in Ireland, particularly among the Catholic families. He suggests that the surplus population of impoverished children could be a burden on society.
How doe this passage affect the readers interpretation of the title a modest proposal?
This passage likely adds a layer of irony to the title "A Modest Proposal" by suggesting that the proposal being made is not actually modest or reasonable at all. It may make the reader question the true intentions or seriousness behind the proposal, leading to a more critical interpretation of the title.
Why do you think he gradually reveals the real nature of the proposal in the modest proposal?
Swift uses irony and satire in "A Modest Proposal" to shock readers into recognizing the harsh realities of poverty in Ireland. By gradually revealing the true nature of the proposal to consume children as a solution to poverty, Swift forces readers to confront their indifference towards the suffering of the poor and challenges societal attitudes towards the Irish.
How does Swift use adjectives and descriptive phrases to convince his readers of his absurd proposal?
Jonathan swift uses mainly satire to convince his readers of his absurd proposal. In a " A Modest Proposal" he makes an argument that the lower classes in Ireland deserve a comfortable living.
These best describes A Modest Proposal?
"A Modest Proposal" is a satirical essay written by Jonathan Swift in 1729. The essay suggests an outlandish solution to poverty in Ireland by proposing that impoverished families should sell their children as food to wealthy individuals. The proposal highlights the callousness of British policy towards Irish poverty and serves as a critique of political and economic exploitation.
When was A Modest Proposal created?
"A Modest Proposal" was written by Jonathan Swift in 1729.
What is ironic about the speaker's rejection of other solutions to Ireland's problem in a modest proposal?
The irony lies in the speaker's extreme proposal of eating children as a solution to Ireland's economic issues. While the speaker rejects other less extreme solutions, such as fair trade and improving conditions for the poor, his proposed solution is both shocking and inhumane. This highlights the absurdity and satire in Swift's "A Modest Proposal."
What is the persona of a modest proposal?
In "A Modest Proposal," the persona is a rational and detached speaker who suggests using infants for food as a solution to poverty in Ireland. The persona presents the idea with logical arguments and a serious tone, maintaining a satirical distance from the horrifying proposal.
