0
Okay, well, my viewpoint is:
the reason why one could argue that Socrates was a "common" sophist (being payed for knowledge) is, because he also got payed for his knowledge, more often with (personal) favours than with monay, but he was payed. so far the conventional Sophist.
deeper:
sophist as in altering his knowledge as to suit what people expect, or being payed for.
well, when conquering people with questions that lead to further questions, it is inevitable to keep on questioning and not agreeing on something eventually. so here it is probable that he contradicted his own viewpoint just to prove that another person did not have an answer to this question.
secondly, in "Apology" (thats how the text was called that we had in our lecture) he says he will not bring his family into the courtroom, but he mentioned it and that alone already contradicts his "not using his family to gain extra points".
that, for now, is the only (possible) explenation i could give :)
Greetings
Socrates was not a Sophist; he was a philosopher who engaged in critical questioning and seeking knowledge through dialogue. Sophists focused on rhetoric and persuasion for personal gain, while Socrates aimed to seek truth and wisdom through logical reasoning and self-examination.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why does Plato feel that Socrates was a Sophist?
Plato believes that Socrates was mistaken for a Sophist because of his thought-provoking questioning style and his focus on challenging conventional beliefs. However, Socrates differed from the Sophists in that he did not accept payment for his teachings and sought after truth rather than personal gain. Plato aimed to distinguish Socrates from the Sophists by portraying him as a philosopher who pursued wisdom and virtue, rather than being motivated by debate or rhetoric.
Compare socrates and the sophist?
Socrates was a philosopher who believed in the pursuit of wisdom and virtue through questioning and self-examination. Sophists, on the other hand, were professional teachers who were more concerned with teaching persuasive techniques and argumentation skills. While Socrates sought knowledge as an end in itself, sophists focused on the practical application of rhetoric and debate for personal gain.
Who wrote play called the clouds that made fun of the philosopher Socrates?
The play "Clouds" that made fun of the philosopher Socrates was written by the ancient Greek playwright Aristophanes. In the play, Socrates is portrayed as a sophist who teaches absurd theories to his students, mocking his unconventional philosophical ideas.
Did Protagoras invent the Socratic Method?
No, Protagoras did not invent the Socratic Method. He was a prominent Sophist who focused on teaching persuasive speaking skills. The Socratic Method is associated with Socrates, who used a question-and-answer approach to stimulate critical thinking and dialogue.
Socrates notion of wisdom in response to the sophist?
Socrates believed that true wisdom comes from acknowledging one's own ignorance, while the sophists claimed to have knowledge that they could teach others for a fee. Socrates viewed philosophy as a pursuit of truth through self-examination and questioning, rather than a commodity to be bought and sold like the sophists did. Ultimately, Socrates viewed wisdom as an ongoing process of inquiry and self-reflection, rather than a set of fixed teachings to be disseminated.
Where Sophist the same as Socrates?
Socrates would roll over in his grave if he could see this question. Socrates, his pupil Plato and later Aristotle all opposed the Sophist philosophy. Although most written examples of the sophists come from either Plato or Aristotle, it was largely reported that the Sophists used the art of Rhetoric to pursuade people on issues of truth and morality. Socrates felt that because the goal of Rhetoric was to pursuade rather than seek truth, he criticized the sophist philosophy. I should know. I am a sophist. Michael U.C. Berkeley, class of '93 Rhetoric Major
Did the sophist believe in god?
Socrates did not believe in the singular God of Judaism, Christianity, or Islam.
Why does Plato feel that Socrates was a Sophist?
Plato believes that Socrates was mistaken for a Sophist because of his thought-provoking questioning style and his focus on challenging conventional beliefs. However, Socrates differed from the Sophists in that he did not accept payment for his teachings and sought after truth rather than personal gain. Plato aimed to distinguish Socrates from the Sophists by portraying him as a philosopher who pursued wisdom and virtue, rather than being motivated by debate or rhetoric.
Is socrates a sophist?
Socrates was an opponent of the Sophists. He believed that the Sophists only taught opinions instead of teaching students to find the truth for themselves.
Why were the sophists condemned by older citizen?
They weren't. The Sophists were condemned by Socrates, according to Plato. Aristophanes, on the other hand, claims that Socrates was himself a Sophist no different from any other one.
Compare socrates and the sophist?
Socrates was a philosopher who believed in the pursuit of wisdom and virtue through questioning and self-examination. Sophists, on the other hand, were professional teachers who were more concerned with teaching persuasive techniques and argumentation skills. While Socrates sought knowledge as an end in itself, sophists focused on the practical application of rhetoric and debate for personal gain.
Who wrote play called the clouds that made fun of the philosopher Socrates?
The play "Clouds" that made fun of the philosopher Socrates was written by the ancient Greek playwright Aristophanes. In the play, Socrates is portrayed as a sophist who teaches absurd theories to his students, mocking his unconventional philosophical ideas.
What is a sentence for sophist?
Sophist were the teachers who basically taught philosophy. This is a sentence using the word sophist.
When was sophists born and where?
when was sophist born and wherewhy was sophist important
When did Asterius the Sophist die?
Asterius the Sophist died in 341.
How did philosophy start?
Thales of Miletus is usually regarded as the first "philosopher". More particularly, he is the first of the Greek "Pre-socratic" philosophers (philosophers before Socrates). Thales and the other presocratics are sometimes called "sophists", and Socrates was a sort of anti-sophist who used a method of interrogation ("the elenchus") to reveal the ignorance and confusion behind the sophist's claims to knowledge. Against the sophists, who claimed to be wise, Socrates and his followers called themselves "philosophers", that is, "lovers of wisdom", to show that they were still trying to figure out the answers, and did not yet claim to have the final answers to everything.
Did Protagoras invent the Socratic Method?
No, Protagoras did not invent the Socratic Method. He was a prominent Sophist who focused on teaching persuasive speaking skills. The Socratic Method is associated with Socrates, who used a question-and-answer approach to stimulate critical thinking and dialogue.
