answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Yes. In fact, it's quite obvious that Emily is Homer's killer.

She had motive: Homer was about to jilt her and leave town.

Opportunity: Homer was last seen alive entering her house, until he was seen dead in the house, on Emily's bed with a lock of her hair on the pillow beside the corpse.

Means: She had purchased arsenic at the drugstore shortly before Homer was last seen going into Emily's house.

User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

AnswerBot

5mo ago

In "A Rose for Emily," there is no clear consensus among critics about whether Emily actually killed Homer Barron. Some argue that she did to preserve their relationship, while others suggest that the evidence is not definitive enough to confirm her guilt. Ultimately, the story leaves this question open to interpretation.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Do crtics think Emily killed Homer barron in 'A Rose for Emily'?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

What poison did Emily use to kill homer barron?

Emily used arsenic to poison Homer Barron.


Why did Emily kill Homer Barron?

Miss Emily killed Homer Barron so that he could never leave her. She had already suffered with her father dieing and leaving her. Then the towns people took him away and buried him. She was able to keep her crime of killing Homer a secret and she kept him locked up in the room for forty-years.


Who are the major characters in a rose for Emily?

Homer Barron , Emily Grierson , Emily's Father and Tobe .


Who began to date Miss Emily in part iii and why was he in town in 'A Rose for Emily'?

Homer Barron begins to date Miss Emily in Part III of "A Rose for Emily." He was in town as a construction foreman overseeing a project to pave the sidewalks. Emily's relationship with Homer Barron becomes a significant focus of the story.


Who is Homer Barron in A Rose for Emily?

Homer Barron is a character in William Faulkner's short story "A Rose for Emily." He is a Northerner who comes to Jefferson to work on construction projects and begins a romantic relationship with Emily Grierson. Ultimately, he disappears and is later discovered to have been dead in Emily's house. Emily's keeping of his body reveals her descent into madness.


Why is it according to the townspeople that homer barron would not marry Emily?

Gvhb


Who was not from the south in the short story 'A Rose for Emily'?

Homer Barron, the unfortunate suitor of Emily Grierson, was not from the south.


Why does Emily date Homer Barron?

Emily dates Homer Barron because he is a Northerner who stands out in the small Southern town of Jefferson, which excites and interests her. Additionally, Homer is a prominent figure in the town, giving Emily company and social status. She may also feel a sense of control and power in the relationship with Homer.


What happened to Homer Barron?

Homer Barron, a character in A Rose for Emily, dies and Emily keeps his body in her house. When the townsfolk enter the house after Emily's death, they see his corpse on a bed with a pillow next to it that has a strand of Emily's hair on in, indicating that she often laid next to his dead body.


What Happens To Miss Emily After Homer Barron Disappears A Rose For Emily?

After Homer Barron disappears, Miss Emily is never seen again for many years. It is later revealed that she had kept Homer's body in her house, sleeping next to it every night. When she dies, her secret is discovered, revealing the extent of her mental instability and obsession with Homer.


Who began to date Miss Emily in part iii and why was he in town in the story A Rose For Emily?

Homer Barron began to date Miss Emily in part III. He was in town as a construction foreman working on a project to pave the sidewalks in the community.


Where and in what comdition is homer barron found?

In William Faulkner's "A Rose for Emily," Homer Barron is found dead in Emily Grierson's bedroom, decades after disappearing. His body is discovered lying on a bed, decomposed, and indented in the pillow next to it, indicating that Emily had been sleeping next to his corpse.