answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

The vices and virtues of determinative sentencing depend largely the theory of punishment you embrace, and your definition of "justice":

For example, determinate sentencing is good if you're aiming at general deterrence because it increases public awareness about what the punishment will be for a given crime, enhancing a punishment's deterrent effect.

Some people might also think that determinative sentencing will increase "fairness" or "justice" in sentencing by reducing the discretion and bias of individual judges and juries. This is positive because some judges and juries may tend towards harsher sentences than others, may be sensitive to certain races or genders, or may consider irrelevant factors in making the sentencing decision. Proponents of determinate sentencing would say: at least there's consistency.


The problem with this is that consistency is not actually the same as fairness. Even though discretion can introduce prejudice into sentencing, discretion also allows judges to make individualized determinations, which better fit the defendant's blameworthiness. Non-determinate sentencing, therefore, is better from the retributivist standpoint: the judge can consider the defendant's mental state, testimony, background, and individual circumstances-- things that determinate sentences won't account for. Even though determinate sentencing may include sentencing grids or formulas (accounting for prior convictions and other mitigating and aggravating factors), these bright-line rules will always be over- or under-inclusive.

User Avatar

Wiki User

15y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

A prison term that is definite and not subject to review by parole board or other agency.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: What are the pros and cons of determinate sentencing?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

Which type of sentencing in juvenile justice is replacing the traditional form of indeterminate sentencing in most of the jurisdictions in the US?

Determinate sentencing. Pg 146


What is the difference between indeterminate and determinate sentencing in law?

Indeterminate sentencing allows for a range of possible release dates, determined by a parole board based on the individual's behavior while in prison. Determinate sentencing mandates a fixed term of imprisonment without the possibility of parole or early release. Determinate sentencing provides more certainty in terms of the length of incarceration, while indeterminate sentencing allows for flexibility based on the inmate's conduct.


What structured sentencing models are in use today?

The most common structured sentencing models in use today include determinate sentencing, indeterminate sentencing, and sentencing guidelines. Determinate sentencing involves fixed terms for specific crimes, while indeterminate sentencing allows for a range of time to be served based on individual behavior. Sentencing guidelines provide a framework for judges to consider various factors in determining appropriate sentences.


The pros and cons of physiocrats?

The physiocrats were an 18th-century group of French economists who believed in the importance of agriculture as the primary source of wealth in society. Their main pro was their focus on the natural order of the economy and the idea that wealth came from the land. However, their main con was their limited view of economic activity, as they often overlooked the role of manufacturing and trade in creating wealth. Additionally, their ideas were not always practical or easily implemented in complex modern economies.


What is determinate sentencing?

Determinate sentences require a fixed period of confinement, with possible reduction for parole. A legislature fixes the terms for particular crimes. This differs from indeteminate sentencing in which the sentence has a maximum and a minimum length of time served.


Pros and cons of jury selection?

what were the pros and cons for the nulification


What is pros and cons of the Oregon Trail?

pros an cons of the Oregon trail


What are the pros and cons of evidence based policing?

pros are + and cons are-


What are the pros and cons of monarchy?

pros: goodness cons: badness


List pros and cons of video games?

PROS CONS ----------------------------------------------------- Pros: Entertaining Cons: Mental conditions can be caused, Adicition, Expensive.


Pros and cons of pornography?

Cons? What Cons?


Pros and cons of transformational leadership?

What are the pros and cons of transformational leadership?