answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

No, they are not. This stereotype comes from the casual observer's misunderstanding of Jewish culture. Jews often use their intellect to succeed rather than their hands which often leads them into business roles and entrepreneurship instead of physical labor.

In truth generosity runs in the veins of many Jews and in fact the very existence of The United States of America can be traced to the generosity of a Jew named Haim Solomon who funded George Washington's efforts and died a pauper because of it.

In Jewish culture, it is considered of the utmost importance that you are able to provide for your family. If you should die, or if your son or daughter should come down with some horrible and very expensive medical condition, or if a tornado should destroy your home and all of your belongings, you want to have enough money for your family to survive. It is not wealth that's important; it's financial security.

Moreover, the mitzva (command) of charity (Deuteronomy ch.15) is central to Judaism.

Of course there may be some Jews who are actually greedy, just as there are greedy people in any group. The question itself implies that all Jewish people have the same personality trait which is ridiculous.
I'll answer that by saying that, unless you've personally conducted a statistically

significant survey of Jewish personality types and characteristics and formulated

a conclusion based on your own observations, then the reason it might seem that way

to someone is the fact that it's what you've been taught and heard from so many directions

for so long.

-- One reason for the stereotype may be the casual observer's misunderstanding

of Jewish culture. Jews often use their intellect to succeed rather than their hands,

which often leads them into business roles and entrepreneurship instead of physical labor.

-- How did that get started ? Why are Jews typically not factory workers or farmers

like many others? In the Middle Ages, Jews were excluded from the tradesmens'

guilds, and prohibited by the church from owning land, but they were still required

to support their families and pay the king's taxes. The only remaining honest means

of making a living were banking and business ... which made it easy for their anti-semitic

detractors to grab the convenient and available stereotype of greed.

-- The very existence of The United States of America can be traced to the generosity

of a Jew named Haim Solomon who funded George Washington's efforts and died a pauper

because of it.

-- In Jewish culture, it is considered of the utmost importance that you are able to

provide for your family. If you should die, or if your son or daughter should come down

with some horrible and very expensive medical condition, or if a tornado should destroy

your home and all of your belongings, you want to have enough money for your family

to survive. It is not wealth that's important; it's financial security. A well-known

Hebrew proverb, dating from the Mishnah and quoted and re-quoted through several

centuries, asks "Who is the rich one?" and answers "The one who is satisfied with

what he has."

-- The commandment of charity (Deuteronomy ch.15) is central to Judaism.

If you'd like to conduct a survey that makes sense, go on line and search the

names of schools, hospitals, and nursing homes in different cities. See how many

"Jewish names" pop up in that kind of search, then ask yourself "How do they get

their names attached to those places?". Hint: It's not because somebody knew

the architect and slipped him a few bucks to paint their name on the door.

-- Full disclosure: There are some greedy Jews. There are also some greedy Baptists,

Amish, Methodists, Catholics, Anglicans, Buddhists, Muslims, Taoists, Uighur, Atheists

and Hindus. To imply that all Jewish people share a common and unique character trait

is absurd.

User Avatar

Wiki User

βˆ™ 8y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Are Jews greedy
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about General History

Why were the Jews greedy with money to the Germans?

They weren't. Considering that Germany did not allow Jews to do much of anything, the Jewish people were not greedy with money to the Germans or anyone else for that matter. This was just a lie to blame everything on the Jews and to make it easier to kill as many of them as possible.


Was Marco Polo greedy?

yes very greedy


How did Schindler change and list as many scenes?

Schindler made an unlikely but fortunate transformation from a greedy war profiteer to a humanitarian who saved more than a thousand Jews during the Holocaust by employing them in his factories.


How did Nazis view Jews?

The Nazis thought that the Jews were the cause of all sorts of problems in Germany and thought that they were scum, when the Jew's weren't the cause of the problem, the Jews were not evil, it was all the other way around, it's just that Hitler was in charge at the time and made everybody think this.


How were the Jews different from the German during World War 2?

The Jews were considered different from the rest of Germans because they were Jews. They were stereotyped as being greedy and worth less than other Germans. Simply put, all the usual racist stereotypes and general discrimination. The other way to answer this is that they were one of the minorities discriminated against, while the Germans were one of the parties doing the discrimination. Also, for obvious reasons, the Jews sided with the Allies, while the Germans were the main Axis powers. Lastly, the Jews had no major combat involvement in the war. They were often the prisoners in Nazi concentration camps, but they were rarely, if ever, combatants.

Related questions

Why were the Jews greedy with money to the Germans?

They weren't. Considering that Germany did not allow Jews to do much of anything, the Jewish people were not greedy with money to the Germans or anyone else for that matter. This was just a lie to blame everything on the Jews and to make it easier to kill as many of them as possible.


Why are Jews so greddy?

It is not accurate or fair to say that all Jews are greedy. It is a stereotype that has been perpetuated throughout history and has no basis in fact. Like any other group of people, individuals within the Jewish community have a wide range of characteristics, including their attitudes towards money and wealth. It is important to avoid generalizations and recognize the diversity within any religious or ethnic group.


Is Chinese education free?

Umm no. people these days are greedy. sometimes just like greedy jews. they wont give u a FREE penny.


Are Jewishes greedy?

Is there any human trait that is found only in one population and not in another? As a people, Jews are no more greedy or tall or intelligent or ugly or beautiful than any other people.


How do you know if you have a stereoscopic TV?

Say Jews are greedy or Asians are good at maths or even rangas have no soul and see if it nods in agreement.


Why were Jews their primary targets?

They were greedy and wanted to steal everyones moneys. The Holocaust was about eliminating Jews from society, there was no secondary target. This does not take away from the destruction that the Gypsies suffered, it was arguably worse than what the Jews suffered, but this was a separate action, though in the same time and space.


Are Jews greedy with money?

By proportion of population? No more or less than people of any other race,color creed ethnic background or sexual preference.


Are mice greedy?

Yeah. They are greedy


How important is wealth to people?

Wealth and the acquisition of it is as important - and unimportant - to Jews as it is to people of other communities, depending on the importance attached to it by the individual. There are Jews who are greedy and wish to acquire wealth for themselves, there are Jews who wish to create wealth so that it can be used for philanthropic purposes and there are Jews who choose to live an entirely ascetic life free from worldly temptations such as money.


Were greedy for more gold sentence or fragment?

The phrase 'were greedy for more gold' is a fragment. Who was greedy? Correct: The men were greedy for more gold. The miners were greedy for more gold.


Is Eminem greedy?

no eminem is not greedy...


How important is wealth to Jewish people?

Wealth and the acquisition of it is as important - and unimportant - to Jews as it is to people of other communities, depending on the importance attached to it by the individual. There are Jews who are greedy and wish to acquire wealth for themselves, there are Jews who wish to create wealth so that it can be used for philanthropic purposes and there are Jews who choose to live an entirely ascetic life free from worldly temptations such as money.