Who is better Harry Potter or Edward Cullen?

Answer 1

This is a question asking about people's personal opinions and each will be different. Below are some fans thoughts, please add any more to the discussion page.

• Jacob Black is way better than Edward ever dreamed. Plus Jacob isn't a hairy dog like some said. He is hotter and more loyal. I mean who'd want to go out with a cube of tall ice anyway? I never understood Team Edward... He's too ugly. It goes Edward's head would get ripped off and he'd catch on fire from Jake.

• I would pick Edward not because he is hott n crap like that but because he cares for Bella but I'm not saying I don't like Jacob he just does not care about Bella as much as Edward does! Edward will accept if Bella chooses him or Jacob.... Jacob on the other hand will keep fighting for her... he is very loyal to her! Edward will protect her no matter what. That's why I would pick Edward! They both can hurt Bella and they both have helped Bella through high school! I like both.

• This is definitely a matter of opinion on whether on is 'Team Jacob' or 'Team Edward'. I'd advise you to be part of 'Team Switzerland', so you can like both Edward and Jacob without there being much of a fuss. However, I'll answer this question as if you're asking who is better than Bella. Edward is an 'abusive' boyfriend in a way, both physically and emotionally, but he does deeply care and love Bella, and she loves him back with all her heart. Jacob also loves Bella, and she loves him, but she said herself that her love for him was not as strong as her love for Edward. So, if she had gotten with Jacob, she would've always gone to Edward when she got the chance, and thus caused him more pain. Jacob deserves better than someone who's always going to be torn between two men. Jacob should let Bella go, then move on and let himself be happy, like in Breaking Dawn.

• Team Edward because he truly cares for Bella, in New Moon, he leaves her only because he thought he'd be protecting her, even after he and his family left, he still loved her. In Eclipse, Jacob is forcing her to choose between him and Edward, when it's obvious from the first part of Breaking Dawn that she chooses Edward. Yet, she still loves Jacob, she loves Edward so much more. Edward never makes Bella do anything she doesn't want to do, while Jacob just practically made Bella kiss him in Eclipse when he told her that he loved her. Edward only wants her to be happy.

• Jacob is a dog, why would you want to date, marry or kiss a smelly, hairy dog? Edward can at least change Bella so they can be happy for the rest of time, while Jacob cannot do that- unless he changes her into a werewolf, which wouldn't be possible. What is the point in that? Edward is a vampire, and he sparkles! He is drop dead gorgeous, too.

• Many people blame me for my Jacob-loving skills, but I do believe that Jacob is much better than Edward. Edward is wrong for Bella. In Breaking Dawn, he killed her. Not necessarily, though. Bella wanted to have sex with Edward, he should have stopped her from doing it with him. When she was giving birth to her half-vampire child, she was dying, and she had to be turned into a vampire. Now, Bella would be a vampire forever. She was loosing many things, such as family and friends when she was almost 19. Edward took all of this away from her, just because he was too selfish and in love with Bella to say no. I say that Jacob is the best boyfriend in the world to Bella because he doesn't stalk her, or didn't leave her. Edward was leaving for her protection in New Moon, but, instead, he scattered her heart. Team Jacob forever.

• Team Edward because he truly cares for Bella, in New Moon, he leaves her only because he thought he'd be protecting her, even after he and his family left, he still loved her. In Eclipse, Jacob is forcing her to choose between him, or Edward, when it's obvious from book 1 that she chooses Edward, yet she still loves Jacob, but not the same way as she loves Edward. Edward never makes Bella do anything she doesn't want to do, while Jacob just practically makes her kiss him. Edward only wants her to be happy.

• For me, I say Team Edward, not because of his sexiness (though he's very sexy) but because it seems to me that he really truly cares about Bella, and her decisions, if for some odd reason she were to choose Jacob, Edward would let her go, instead of getting madly obsessive and going after her. Jacob is mean towards Edward, Edward at least tries to control himself. Besides, Jacob is a smelly dog that doesn't seem to own a shirt, like seriously, does he always have to be shirtless? Edward is just... right for her, there are no words that can describe the love he holds for her. Jacob is making her choose between him, or Edward when she made is pretty obvious that it's Edward, and not him. He just can't seem to accept it, that she loves him as a friend, and nothing more, that's all she wants it to be between them, but he wont take no for an answer. Besides, who would want to date a smelly dog, he's all hairy and disgusting. I mean, I know Edward is technically an old man, but he looks 17 and hotter than Jacob will ever be. But Edward is over 100 years old, he has a lot of experience in the 'love' department, who wouldn't want that? Like, seriously. It would take an imbecile to know that Bella chooses Edward from the very beginning.

• In the book series Edward Cullen by far was the superior of the two. In the movies however.. Since Jacob is played by the drool worthy Taylor Lautner, that makes him superior. Though Character wise.. Edward for the win.

• It all depends on what you would rather a: hot bad boy werewolf that has abs of steel or a cool good boy vampire that sparkles in the sun. With me I would have to say team Switzerland because I love Jacob he is hot and he is perfect for Bella because they are best friends and you have to be friends first for it to work and I like Edward because he is a vampire even if he is a crappy type vampire that sparkles he is still a vampire. So Team Switzerland!

• Jacob is the best. He is sexy and tan unlike Edward and his abs are real. Edward's abs are fake! Jacob loves Bella and if Bella and Jacob are together Bella won't have to change for him. They can get married and they can have children and be a normal family. Jacob is human and alive, a real person. Jacob has a real live beating heart. If Bella is with Jacob she won't have to leave her friends and family and be all secretive with them. Edward is not human or alive. He is pale, has no heart, he is stone. Edward needs to trust Bella and give her some space and stop being so protective

• This is anything but true. A. They could never be a normal family and have normal children because furry boy is, and will always be a werewolf, so Bella will practically have puppies. And Jacob isn't human, idiot, he's a werewolf. So you might as well stop speaking in hypothetical sense, because Bella has made up her mind, she loves Edward.

• Personally I would pick team Jacob. He isn't freezing cold and dead. Also Edward has nothing special about him he's boring and no fun at all. But I guess That means Bella and Edward would be a perfect match. Anyway in the scene when Jacob took off his shirt he had so much more color to his body. When Edward took off his shirt I had to look away he is so white and pasty it's disgusting.

• Team Edward because he truly cares for Bella, in New Moon, he leaves her only because he thought he'd be protecting her, even after he and his family left, he still loved her. In Eclipse, Jacob is forcing her to choose between him, or Edward, when it's obvious from book 1 that she chooses Edward, yet she still loves Jacob, but not the same way as she loves Edward. Edward never makes Bella do anything she doesn't want to do, while Jacob just practically makes her kiss him. Edward only wants her to be happy.

• You are totally wrong. Bella should be with Jacob. The reason why is because Jacob treats her better, knows her better, and we all know she wants a little werewolf. For instance she wanted to kiss Jacob so bad in New Moon (the book). I mean Edward doesn't really like her. because in the book New Moon he tells her to be happy, be with Jacob.

• When Bella kissed Jacob she was confused about how she felt about him. even though she later found out she was in love with him too she didn't know it when she first kissed him. She has never her love for Edward and he has always wanted to be with and spend the rest of her life with him and Edward clearly feels the same way about her. He was trying to protect her, that's all he ever wanted to do, from day one and even though Jacob loves her very much he's always let the fact that she chose Edward effect the he treated Bella. Edward never treated her that way he just wanted her to be happy.

• Bella loves both Jacob and Edward.but in different ways as she states many times in the series. Although I believe she should be with with Jacob because, after Edward left he was the one who showed that he cared about her. But Edward is very hard to resist he definitely cares alot about her. He left Bella because he thought it would be better for her to live a 'human' life. Bella could be with Jacob or Edward. They both care about her and love her. I would have liked it if Bella had ended up with Jacob though. Even though Bella was confused she definitely had a conecton with Jacob, he knew her so well considering they were best friends. It worked out well though because Edward and Bella will now live a long and happy life together. Meanwhile she still has her best friend Jacob. And he is happy with Renesmee.

• I think that Jacob is perfect for Bella, but she has fallen in alot of love with, Edward. But, Bella does have a side to her that has feelings and love for Jacob... But, Jacob has fallen in alot of love with Bella... But, in New Moon.. Bella admitted to Jacob that Edward was the one for her.. In my opinon, (Jacob is better!) Edward might be the one for her, but to me Jacob is!! In the movie, New Moon, Jacob promised Bella he'd never hurt her and Edward did. In the movie, Eclipse, Jacob said, "I'm gonna fight for you until your heart stops beating."

Answer 2

Jacob is the best. He is sexy and has a tan unlike Edward. Also, his abs are real. Edward's abs are fake! Jacob loves Bella, if Bella and Jacob are together Bella won't have to change for him. They can get married, they can have children and they can be a normal family. Jacob is human and alive- a real person. Jacob has a real live beating heart. If Bella is with Jacob she won't have to leave her friends and family and be secretive with them. Edward is not human or alive. He is pale, has no heart- he is stone. Edward needs to trust Bella, give her some space and stop being so protective!!!! Vampires suck! Werewolves rule!!

TELL THEM SISTER! GO JACOB! -JAGA5

lol

Answer 3

Edward loves her, and wants whats best for her. In the film 'eclipse' we saw that Edward tried to kill himself when he thought Bella was dead.

Jacob also loves her, but he is selfish towards her and just wants to have her rather than wanting her to choose who she wants. The only good thing between Bella and Jacob would probably be the fact that he is reluctant against her becoming a vampire, but that is most likely because he loves her and doesn't want her to gain more reasons to be with Edward.

Overall, my person opinion would be that Edward has the better personality, but it all depends on which way you look at it.

1Dfanatic xo.

Answer 4

Answer: neither is better than the other. But if had to pick one I'd say Harry Potter because Harry is more heroic and Edward is more Romantic i guess it's one of those opinion

questions depends on the person you are speaking to

Answer: Different people will likely have different opinions. I suggest you read both books or series of books, or watch both movies or series of movies, and decide which you like best.
Harry Potter, he is a well developed character who people can relate too. Nobody can relate to a perfect sparkly vampire. Harry is a nicer person as well whereas Edward is controlling.

I agree with the person above me. And Edward is so... frightening. And yea Harry Potter is MUCH more relatable to than Edward.

I totally agree. Harry Potter is much easier to relate to, quite nice, and has faced much MUCH more than Edward Cullen.
they both have good traits and bad traits

Harry Potter is much better, he is easy to relate to, quite nice, and has faced much MUCH more than Edward Cullen. They are, however, equal in the way that they are magical. But still, HARRY POTTER FOREVER

Answer 5

Everyone has their different opinions!

What are you, team Edward or Team Jacob?

To find out, who do you think is the best looking, and who has the best personality?

From Meffietwilightvamp, your Vampire Genius.

Answer 6

Okay ladies i think we all know it is Edward! he is SO hot and romantic we all love them except the haters who love the ugly ass Jakob. He is the most hottest guy from the dead!!

Answer 7

Both are awsome in their own ways.

Emmett- Down right funny.

Jasper- Caring and calming

Answer 8

JACOB of course!!!!

Answer 9

Jacob is the best