He threatened to leave the Dwarves. Knowing that Gandalf was powerful and wise, Thorin realised what a dangerous journey it would be if Gandalf was not with them. Gandalf also reminded the Dwarves that they were thirteen, and unless they accepted Bilbo, they would remain that many. Being highly superstitious, the Dwarves shuddered at the thought of setting out for such a perilous journey with a number as evil as 13.
No they are not. Bilbo is simple hobbit from the Shire, Thorin is a dwarf.
Bilbo Baggins was famously a hobbit, not a dwarf.
Bilbo takes possession of the Arkenstone without telling Thorin.
Thorin rekindled his friendship with Bilbo before he died because he realized the importance of their bond and the loyalty and bravery Bilbo had shown during their journey. Additionally, Thorin recognized that Bilbo's actions were instrumental in their success, and he wanted to make amends for his earlier distrust and mistreatment of Bilbo. Finally, Thorin's impending death also likely prompted him to seek reconciliation and closure with Bilbo before it was too late.
Bilbo took the Arkenstone. It was the treasure Thorin desired most.
No they are not. Bilbo is simple hobbit from the Shire, Thorin is a dwarf.
Bilbo Baggins was famously a hobbit, not a dwarf.
Bilbo takes possession of the Arkenstone without telling Thorin.
burglar
Thorin rekindled his friendship with Bilbo before he died because he realized the importance of their bond and the loyalty and bravery Bilbo had shown during their journey. Additionally, Thorin recognized that Bilbo's actions were instrumental in their success, and he wanted to make amends for his earlier distrust and mistreatment of Bilbo. Finally, Thorin's impending death also likely prompted him to seek reconciliation and closure with Bilbo before it was too late.
Bilbo took the Arkenstone. It was the treasure Thorin desired most.
When Thorin learned of Bilbo's treachery he kicked him out and said that the 1/14 share promised to Bilbo would be used to buy back the Arkenstone. He figured Bilbo would get little of it.
He forgives Bilbo for stealing the Arkenstone, and then tells Bilbo that everyone should be like the hobbits: more concerned with comfort than with treasure. Then Thorin dies. He is buried with the Arkenstone, and Dain, Thorin's cousin, is proclaimed the new king.
When they first get to the treasure trove. Thorin gives it to Bilbo as part of his payment.
Thorin was dying, he had been mortally wounded in the Battle of Five Armies. He wanted to make his peace with Bilbo before he died. Bilbo was found and brought to him just in time.
Bilbo Baggins gave the elvenking the Arkenstone, the prized possession of Thorin.
Bilbo was very careful to plug up all the holes in the barrels.