Tags The Catcher in the Rye

Animals & Plants Arts & Entertainment Auto Beauty & Health Books and Literature Business Electronics Engineering & Technology Food & Drink History Hobbies Jobs & Education Law & Government Math People & Society Science Social Studies Sports Travel & Places

0

Subjects>Books and Literature>Fiction

Why did Holden give Phoebe a broken record?

Anonymous

∙ 13y ago

Updated: 3/22/2024

Holden gave Phoebe a broken record to represent his belief that he is unable to keep anything good from becoming corrupted or ruined. He sees himself as being unable to maintain any form of purity or innocence in his own life or in the lives of those he cares about. The broken record symbolizes his feelings of anguish and helplessness in the face of perceived inevitable destruction.

AnswerBot

∙ 12mo ago

Still curious? Ask our experts.

Chat with our AI personalities

Beau

You're doing better than you think!

Chat with Beau

Devin

I've poured enough drinks to know that people don't always want advice—they just want to talk.

Chat with Devin

Rene

Change my mind. I dare you.

Chat with Rene

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts

Q: Why did Holden give Phoebe a broken record?

Write your answer...

Submit

Still have questions?

imp

Trending Questions

What does non-fan fiction mean? What part of the story does the reader learns the final out come? In To Kill a Mockingbird what two comments specifically infuriate jem to the point that he cant control his anger? Why did calpurina serve atticus such a big breakfast after the trial? What is mayellas testimony? History of ilonggo tribe? How many people practice bondage? What does atticus save from ms Maudie's house? What would you put in Scout's memory box? How is the conflict resolved in ruined by Paula Morris? What is summary of the clever crow story? What do the constant references to gender say about okonkwo? When was the book Night john published? what type of character changes or evolves throughout the story? Was there a character in the 1980 movie The Shining called Jeeves or Cheeves? How do you keep count of the words when writing a novel? What do Mr Boone and Mr Schmidt argue about? Why does Macbeth take the witches predictions seriously? Is Professor Faber a round character in Fahrenheit 451? Is don quixote an idealist or a realist?

Related Questions

What does holden give phoebe?

Holden gives Phoebe his red hunting hat as a gift. He originally bought the hat for himself but gives it to Phoebe as a gesture of affection and to provide her with comfort and protection.

What does the Broken Record in The Catcher in the Rye symbolize?

The "Little Shirley Beans" record represents childhood and Holden wants to give it to Phoebe because he wants her to stay a child forever. The record plays the same song and never changes, just as how he does not want Phoebe to change, and the breaking of the record symbolizes the problem in Holden's plan and how he cannot actually keep her a child forever.

What does phoebe represent in The Catcher in the Rye to Holden?

Phoebe represents innocence, authenticity, and closeness to Holden in "The Catcher in the Rye." She embodies the purity and childhood innocence that Holden desires to protect in a world that he sees as full of phoniness and corruption. Their relationship highlights Holden's longing for connection and his deep-rooted desire to preserve innocence in a world he perceives as harsh and deceitful.

Why did holden cry when phoebe offered him her Christmas money?

he didnt want take it, but she told him to just give it back to her.

What is the best gift to give Holden Caufield?

The record he broke

What is the name of the record holden give his sister in The Catcher in the Rye?

Little Shirley Beans

Why did Holden give the Red Hunting Hat to Phoebe?

He gave it to her, simply, because it began to rain and he wanted to protect her. However, when she was wearing his hat and carrying his suitcase, it made him realize Phoebe is following directly in his footsteps. This is what makes him change his mind about running away from home.

How does holden treat little kids in catcher in the rye give an example?

Holden treats little kids with care and kindness, as he values their innocence and sees them as pure. An example of this is when he takes his little sister Phoebe on the carousel in Central Park and watches her enjoy the ride, cherishing the moment and wanting to protect her from the harsh realities of the world.

Who were the three girls looking for in the bar in Catcher in the Rye?

In "The Catcher in the Rye," the three girls were looking for Eddie Birdsell, a friend of Holden's who they wanted to speak with. However, Eddie was not at the bar, so they ended up spending time with Holden instead.

What did Phoebe give Clifford from the garden?

A crimson rose

Radio code Holden?

To get your radio code you must go and see your local Holden dealer and they will give you the code with no or a small charge.

What advice does Mr.Spencer give Holden and how does Holden react?

Mr. Spencer advises Holden to apply himself more diligently to his studies and to think about his future. Holden becomes defensive and dismissive, feeling misunderstood and disconnected from Mr. Spencer's perspective.

Still have questions?

imp

Resources

Top Categories

Product

Company

Copyright ©2025 Infospace Holdings LLC, A System1 Company. All Rights Reserved. The material on this site can not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with prior written permission of Answers.