Toledo?
The halfway point between Hanover, MD and Toledo, Ohio falls in or around Indianola, PA.
Toledo
The halfway point between Pelham Drive, Fort Wayne Indiana, and Toledo, Ohio falls in or around Defiance, Ohio. There is no city of Pelham.
Ripley, WV
Caledonia, IL
Davidsburg, MI
Benezette, Pennsylvania is the halfway point between Long Island, New York and Toledo, Ohio. There is approximately 604 miles between New York and Ohio.
Flat Rock, Mi
Middletown, New York is halfway between Manchester & Gettysburg
The halfway point is between Toledo and Ann Arbor, somewhere around Milan.
Hotchkiss, VA.