1937
Buffalo Bill never appeared on a U.S. nickel. A 1937 nickel has a picture of a Native American chieftan on the front, and a buffalo (animal) on the back.
The 3 legged buffalo nickel in 1937
The 3-legged buffalo nickel error happened in 1937, not 1936. It was the result of a botched attempt to repair a damaged die.
The famed 3 legged buffalo nickel has been sought by collectors ever since its existence became known in 1937 [not 1938]. The value of this coin varies depending upon its condition but a PCGS certified MS66 example of this coin sold at auction in the spring of 2005 for $86,250. To see a photograph of the 3 legged buffalo click on the link in "RELATED LINKS".
The 3 legged buffalo nickel in 1937
1937 is an extremely common date for buffalo nickels. Most are worth less than a dollar.
The three legged buffalo nickel in 1937
1937-D is the 3-legged variety, a 3-1/2 legs variety was struck in 1936-D.
Average coins are $1.00-$3.00
The "3-Legged" variety is only known from the Denver Mint. So the coin will have a "D" mintmark on the reverse under FIVE CENTS. Authentic examples of this famous error have a average minumin retail value of $450.00.
If it's real yes, but there are many altered "3 legged" Buffalo's out there that used to have 4 legs so have an expert look at it.